However when Hathaway took on Doty’s case, she shortly realized different issues about Carmignani. Ten years in the past, he was arrested for home violence involving his then-wife, forcing him to resign from the hearth fee after only a few months. (He pleaded no contest to misdemeanor assault.) So when Hathaway noticed Carmignani demanding silence from his girlfriend, she thought, “Yeah, possibly this man has one thing to cover.”
Doty has pleaded not responsible to expenses of battery and assault. Then, in late April, on the eve of his preliminary listening to, prosecutors despatched Hathaway a brand new batch of proof, together with a steady sequence of footage from the laundromat digicam. For the primary time, Hathaway watched Carmignani’s preliminary method towards Doty, which befell 9 minutes earlier than the beginning time of the clip that Carmignani’s legal professional had launched.
This outdated clip began with Doty ripping a pole out of a trash can. Within the new footage, Carmignani, sporting a Covid face masks, walks previous a jumble of objects on the sidewalk and pulls a big black cartridge from his pocket, the thumb set off on prime. A number of seconds later, Doty, together with his crimson hat, rushes into the body with a jacket pulled over his head. As they face one another, Carmignani walks in the direction of Doty, who shortly turns his again and walks away. Carmignani follows him. There is no sound, however the physique language is telling: Doty is defensive.
The subsequent shock Hathaway encountered within the new batch of proof was a set of police stories, detailing eight crimes dedicated over the earlier yr and a half. Every time, a suspect approached homeless folks on the sidewalks of the Marina and sprayed them with pepper spray. Within the first case, in November 2021, there was even video proof, from a Ring digicam, immediately on Magnolia Road. When Hathaway performed the clip, she noticed a cumbersome man method a person mendacity on the sidewalk and spray him for a full 5 seconds, fastidiously aiming the chemical agent – designed to trigger ache, burns and non permanent blindness – on the sufferer’s face. and head as he turns and stands up. “I used to be like What ? What?!” Hathaway remembers. “It focuses on the sufferer’s face. It is so disgusting.
Hathaway reviewed the 2021 sprayer: a Covid face masks, a surefooted and hulking, a baseball cap. Then she checked out Carmignani as he approached Doty on April 5 – sure-footed, cumbersome, face masks, baseball cap. “I used to be like, Jesus, it’s Carmignani. As if that was precisely how he labored. (Within the press, Carmignani’s lawyer denied that it was him.)
In a few of the different sprayings, witness statements leaned towards a roughly comparable state of affairs. A white man in his 50s, driving a bicycle, requested if an unhoused man wanted assist earlier than pepper-spraying, kicking and punching him. A white man, 6’1″ tall and roughly 220 kilos, with quick, gentle brown hair, sporting a grey beanie, unzipped a person’s tent and struck him with a 10-inch canister , warning him, “Get out of my city.” A white man, 40 to 50 years outdated, with grayish hair, sprayed Ashley Buck and an unhoused man. In different spraying assaults, descriptions of the suspects had been youthful: one concerned a white or Hispanic man in his 30s driving a grey bicycle, and one other was a white man in his 30s driving a skateboard.